Baikunthapur Tarun Sangha(BTS)

Site visit report for Asha prepared by Anirban Hazra and Dr.Sulekha Hazra

About the Location

Baikunthapur is a village in the Kultali island of the Sunderbans, which are situated in the delta region of the river Ganges in West Bengal. Kultali is the largest island in the Sunderbans with over 200,000 inhabitants. Kultali block consists of several villages under a total of 9 Gram Panchayats. The project area presently consists of the villages of North and South Baikunthapur and 4 other villages, which are under 1 Gram Panchayat and have a population of about 22,000 people.

My mother Sulekha and I visited Baikunthapur on 12th June, 2001. We took a local train from Kolkata (Sealdah South) to reach Mathurapur station on the Lakshmikantapur line. From there we took a shared auto rickshaw to Raidighi (1 hour), which is the place from where the boats going to the Sunderbans leave. We took the boat going towards Moipith. It was about a 2 and 1/2 hour jouney. The country boat with a small motor moved slowly. It was quite crowded and it stopped to pick up or drop off passengers whenever someone on the banks of the river or on the boat signaled for a stop. There were quite a few people on the boat carrying fresh-water fish-seed (live baby fish) in large utensils and it was an interesting sight to see them constantly agitating the water in the utensils by beating it with their hands to aerate it. We reached our destination bank and from there walked to Baikunthapur (about 1 hour).

The road from the riverbank to Baikunthapur village is laid with bricks and has been washed away at several places. There are no pucca roads or motorized vehicles on the island. We saw couple of bicycles but majority of the people were on foot. We saw only two concrete houses on our 5 to 6 km walk to Baikanthapur. Most houses are made up of mud and have sloping thatched roofs. There is no electricity or telephone/telegraph facility anywhere on the island. Very few houses have sanitation facilities. There are few tubewells with hand pumps for drinking water. It is extremely green and damp all around with several ponds. Lot of the land is waterlogged.

The BTS club building seemed to be somewhere in the middle of Baikunthapur village. There are houses all around. The club building itself is a two storeyed pucca building. It seemed like it was the only pucca building around. The rest of the houses were made of mud. The name of the building is displayed in bold letters, which translates from Bengali as "Baikunthapur Tarun Sangha, A rural development endeavor". There are two small rooms (about 20ft X 15ft each) on the first floor. There is a big verandah and then a flat piece of open land on the front side. There is a toilet next to the club and a hand pump about 50 meters away. The rooms have one electric light each, which run on solar cells. There is an inscription on the verandah wall which says that the building has been built by an endowment from Lutheran World Service. One of the rooms of the club is used as an Agricultural Service Center, which is a resource center for sustainable agriculture (without synthetic fertilizers and pesticides) supported by the government. The wall of this room has various charts and posters containing information about seeds, agricultural practices, time of the year when a certain crop variety should be cultivated and a list of medicinal plants which grow in this area and are used as the source of ayurvedic medicines for treating common ailments. (The villagers depend a lot on these traditional auyurvedic medicines because there is no qualified doctor in the village. For any serious medical condition including snake bites, which is quite common, the patients have to be taken to Raidighi. Lot of these patients die on the way to the hospital). There is also a list of plants grown in the nutrition gardens maintained by the ladies. The second room is used for various club activities. There is a cupboard, which contains lot of papers and some common medicines for fever, stomach-upset etc. The second floor of the club is used for holding classes for girls of standard 7 and 8 under a government scheme where these girls are given supplementary help and some vocational training. These girls are mostly the dropouts willing to get back to the normal school. Next to the club, the construction of 3 classrooms is in progress with aid received from a funding agency in Ireland following the devastating cyclone in the Sunderbans in June 1999.

The most notable thing about the location of Baikunthapur village is the very limited communication it has with the outside world. The nearest telephone/telegraph office, college, market and health center is in Raidighi, which is at least 3 and 1/2 hours away (1hr walk to the riverbank and then 2 and 1/2 hours by boat). Because of the lack of information, the people of the island villages are having to reinvent the wheel on various occasions and though the place is extremely rich in natural resources, these have not been sufficiently developed to provide enough income to the people. The villagers are extremely poor. Any education/development related activity should have as its focus, generation of employment for the people by using the abundant local agro-based resources in a sustainable way. This improved local resource utilization then can be used by the people for living better (for example eating a more nutritious diet by growing certain vegetable varieties or by cultivating medicinal plants for ayurvedic medicine) and later for exchanging them for other commodities by finding suitable markets for these products. Some of our observations/suggestions regarding this are given later.

EDUCATION AND COMMUNITY ACTIVITY OF BTS

Presently, on the education front, the role of BTS is mainly to run the primary school, which is called Path Bhavan. There are six levels - Nursery, Kindergarten, and 1st to 4th grades. The curriculum for this school till recently (about 3-4 months back) was the standard West Bengal board curriculum. The teachers however seem very motivated and the parents we spoke to, had a good opinion of Path Bhavan and were happy to send their children to this school in spite of other government schools in the vicinity. Also, Path Bhavan charges each student Rs.5 a month unlike the government schools which are free and the fact that around 160 students still attend Path Bhavan, speaks well of it. The teachers are either 10th standard or 12th standard passed, but seem to be motivated and enjoy teaching. They get a salary of around Rs.500 per month. Sometimes it is slightly more or less depending upon the pattern of how students pay their fees. There were classrooms made of mud for holding these classes, but these were broken down by the 1999 cyclone. The remnants can still be seen next to the club building. So now, the classrooms are held in the verandah of the club, the verandah of a nearby temple and another community room, close by. Presently 3 classrooms are being constructed. At this time, the walls have been erected, but the roof has not yet been made. One of these rooms is 20ftX10ft and the other two are 16ftX10ft. The land for these classrooms which is right next to the club has been donated by the father of one of the primary school teachers. In the proposal given to Asha, BTS plans to construct 3 more classrooms and toilets, so that it has a permanent place for holding all the six classes. The proposal to Asha further talks about the 'Basketful of Fun and Learning' as an addition to the regular curriculum. This has been undertaken in an experimental basis in the last 3-4 months, but because of the school vacations, the programme has not yet been completely established. The team at BTS is still in the process of laying out the logistics for this and will concentrate on it in the coming months. We could not get a clear answer to what exactly the 11 fun and learning activities mentioned in the proposal were. The proposal mentions clay modeling, dance, drama, mathematics, botany, fishery and embroidery. We don't know what the other 4 activities are. It is however understandable that in the present condition, where classes are being held without classrooms, the teachers at BTS are faced with a very big challenge to implement this program. The teachers seemed enthusiastic about developing the program once they were a little more stable on the classroom front.

After going to Path Bhavan, the children are ready for mainstream school in the 5th grade. In 2000-2001, 15 out of the 21 children who were in the 4th grade in Path Bhavan entered 5th grade in regular school. In 1999-2000, the number was 15 out of 22. This year, a boy Sandeep Sahu from Path Bhavan stood 1st out of 400 students in the admission test to standard 5 of mainstream school.

The mothers of the students going to Path Bhavan have parent-teacher meetings every two weeks. At these meetings, a mother said that they discuss the progress of their children with the teachers, talk about hygiene and nutrition and other concerns about the children. Information about infant food and nutrition for the growing children is given. Both parents come to the school once every three months to talk to the teachers.

BTS is trying to reach out to the community through the mothers of the children attending the school and also other women. The men involved with working of BTS seem convinced that educating and empowering women is key for community building. The president of BTS (who is also the headmaster of the nearby government primary school) said that the men learn from the women about agricultural practices like nutrition gardening. The women are divided into groups and are asked to grow certain vegetables in small plots of lands. Experiences are shared at meetings and then if a particular vegetable is successful, the men will cultivate it on a larger scale. The women seemed much more confident than in other villages we have seen in West Bengal. For one, it was a pleasant surprise to see that most of them did not feel the need to cover their heads with the sari, which is an age old custom to show 'respect' for the men.

ABOUT SUSHANTA GIRI

Sushanta Giri is the secretary of BTS and the person who has submitted the proposal. He is a B.A. in English and makes his living by tutoring students of 10th, 11th and 12th grades. He lives in a suburb of Calcutta and has access to the Internet. The Internet has been a great boon to him for getting information. He was very appreciative of the Asha website and said that it helped him get ideas and also contacts of other NGOs and funding agencies. He seemed like an honest and determined young man who is willing to learn and do something for his native village.

Sushanta's story about getting FCRA clearance for the organization is interesting. After he applied for FCRA clearance, he did not get any response for a month. He had heard before that unless he bribed the concerned parties, his clearance would not be granted and there would be no response. Sushanta was very clear about the fact that his organization was doing good work and that he was not going to pay any bribe to get FCRA clearance. So he sent a reminder to the FCRA office with a photocopy of the earlier application. He did this every month for the next six months, each time attaching photocopies of the earlier letters. After this an inspector came down for a site visit. However no action was taken even after the visit of the inspector. Then again Sushanta continued sending reminders every month and when 12 such reminders went unnoticed, he sent copies of all his earlier letters with another reminder indicating that he was sending all these to the home minister as well. He got his FCRA clearance within the next couple of weeks. Thus (yet again) perseverance backed by truth won in the end.

OBSERVATIONS/SUGGESTIONS