VOICE OF PEOPLE - SITE VISIT
REPORT (Nilanjan Adhya)
VOP was founded in 1986 by Swapan
Basu-Mallick. It is an organization active in West Bengal, Orissa and parts of
Bihar. VOP aims to provide means for sustainable development of rural and indigenous
people where the "lowliest and the least" could aspire for a better
life- both economical and social. They achieve this through awareness and
education, skill formation and training, technology transfer, capital
formation, cultural revival, value orientation, health, environment and gender
consciousness.
ASHA-MIT is currently funding a school of theirs called
"Bodhi-Vikas". Details of the project are available at the ASHA
website. The school is located in Nutan Diyarah, which is a small village in
south 24 parganas about 5 k.m away from the southern end of Calcutta. The
closest railway station is also about the same distance. The area is
predominantly rural and sparsely populated and there is just a single road
connecting the village to the railway station. Electricity has reached the
villages, but telephone hasn't. Therefore, the VOP organization doesn't have a
phone connection yet. I was told that within a couple of months phones would be
available in the village. Fishing seems to be the major occupation of people
here. There are others who are auto-rickshaw drivers or vegetable sellers and
people who work as maidservants in houses in Calcutta. It is the sons and
daughters of these people who study in this school.
The school itself is a makeshift structure assembled together by tying straw
mats to bamboo poles with asbestos roofing. Bulbs dimly light the interior and
a couple of tubelights hang tied to the poles. The school is right opposite the
VOP office building which houses the VOP office bearers and some teachers of
the school. The school right now has about 100 students. The split of students
is as follows
Pre-Primary:31,Class One : 20,Class Two: 20,Class Three : 20,Class Four : 6.
Classes begin at 7 a.m. and end at 11 a.m. six days a week. There is no
physical separation between one class and the next. Rather, the classes are
separated by an innovative arrangement of desks and chairs with the teacher at
the center and about 20 students surrounding him on 3 sides. There is a small
blackboard hanging on the wall behind the teacher's chair. On the walls of the
school are posters conveying messages about health, education etc in Bengali.
Ms Maya Karmakar, who is also the VOP secretary general, manages the day to day
functioning of the school. She is assisted by a group of teachers most of whom
live at the VOP building which is right next to the school. There are 4 full
time teachers and one part time teacher with a non-teaching staff. I met some
of the teachers present on that day. Mr. Gautam Bhagat is one of the full time
teachers of the school. He teaches drama, recitation and general knowledge to
the kids. He has been with the school for about 4 years now and says he will
continue with the school for as long as he can, as it is the children who keep
him there. Chandra is another teacher at the school who teaches music,
geography and health. A third person, Tandra, teaches math and Bengali to all
the children. The last full time teacher is Ruma who teaches the children
English and History. There is also a part time teacher who comes from Calcutta
once a week to teach drawing to the children. The teachers appear to be highly
motivated and dedicated.
Here is a brief description of ASHA's involvement in the project as told to me
by Ms Karmakar.
April 17th 1997 - Ms Karmakar sends a letter to Asha introducing
VOP and requesting funds
September 5th 1997 - Devabhaktuni Srikrishna responds from
Asha-MIT. Requests her to submit a proposal on the amount needed and how it
intends to be spent.
September end 1997 - VOP sends proposal requesting 1.05 lakh for
renovating school building and teachers salary.
October 1997 - Abhijit Sarkar visits VOP on behalf of ASHA. He
requests VOP to submit their full budget.
November 11th 1997 - VOP submits budget of 7.73 lakh for school,
salaries and health clinic. ASHA shows interest in funding infrastructure in
the first year. The total amount ASHA sanctions is close to 2.36 lakh to be
paid to VOP in 3 installments. ASHA requests VOP to provide proof of permission
to build on the site.
May 5th 1998 - Sangeetha Chandrakanthan contacts VOP and says she
would be the primary ASHA contact.
(Then there is a whole period of more than a year where apparently there is no
contact between ASHA and VOP)
July 10th 1999 : Srikanth Voorakaranam sends an email to Ms Maya
Karmakar with a set of detailed questions about the project. Ms Karmakar
responds with answers to his questions.
Aug 30th 1999: ASHA dispatches a check of $3000 to VOP. Says
another $3000 will be dispatched after 5 months on receipt of photographs,
accounts etc.
September 22nd 1999: Amount gets credited into VOP account.
October 8th 1999 : AMEX says due to insufficient funds the money
couldn't be collected from ASHA. Check bounces.
November 1st 1999 :ASHA deposits check into VOP account for
$3000.
November 30th 1999 : AMEX confirms deposit of amount into VOP
account.
Ms Karmakar told me that the right time to build the school would have been in
October due to the Durga Puja vacations. This would have enabled them to finish
the school before the students came back, without any interruption in their
classes. However, due to the problems with the funds this didn't materialize.
Right now she feels that the school should be able to be built in about a
month's time provided all the funds are available. The amounts to about $6000,
of which $3000 have already been sent. She is hesitant on completing half of
the school and waiting for more funds for a couple of reasons. The primary
reason seems to be that the children have to be temporarily housed in the VOP
office building for their classes. This is going to be problem as the VOP
office doesn't have the required space to hold five separate classes. She would
prefer that this inevitable disruption be for as short a time as possible. Therefore,
she prefers to complete the project at one time instead of splitting it up.
Another reason is that much of the effort towards building the school appears
to be voluntary. There are logistical difficulties associated with getting
these people over 2 periods. Besides given the government requirements
requiring every school to complete examination requirements by May every year,
she doesn't want to risk the project continuing into May.
Ms Karmakar told me that she plans to start building the school starting the
3rd week of January. Ms Karmakar is ready to commit the following. Should the
money be received by February, she should be able to finish the project in
about a month. She wasn't able to start the project earlier than this because
of severe floods in West Bengal towards October end which required her to
provide shelter to many local residents whose houses were washed away. Also she
wasn't at VOP in December as she was attending a women's conference in Beijing.
The future plans for the school includes adding a class every year. Right now
the current plans for the upcoming building would enable them to house up to
classes 6. She would require further permission to build an additional floor to
house more classes in subsequent years, but she doesn't perceive this as a
problem. The final goal is to have this school provide education upto class 10.
For More Information:
Voice Of People
Nutan Diyarah, P.O. Nayabad
Via - Garia Station Road (East)
Dist, 24 Paraganas (South) Pin - 743369
West Bengal , India
Phone: (033)471-4311 (Mr. Joy Sarkar)
Fax : (033)2479163
Pager: (033)9628300143
Email: vopindia@hotmail.com